For years the core crew has smoked and talked in my garage in Gilbertsville. These days we record it on Tuesday nights. When we turned the cameras on, nothing changed.
Episode 71 changed one thing. It was a Friday, it was noon, and we were at the Chartwell Cigar Club in Glenmoore, Pennsylvania. We had new wireless mics and no garage to hide behind. I opened the afternoon by forgetting to hit record.
Table of Contents
We lost three minutes. The crew let me hear about it, which is fair. We had all chipped in on the mics, and this was a dry run before we head to the LA Cigar Collective next week. Eric, Walt, and Eddie fly out Thursday at 8 a.m. and come home Sunday. Better to botch the setup here than in front of a room full of people down there.
Why We Drive Down to Chartwell
Bruce told us about this place. He’s been a member since pretty much day one. A few of us remembered the shop from before, when it went downhill under new ownership. I won’t name names. We expected a hole in the wall, and we walked into a room that feels bigger than it is.
Will, the owner, opened on June 1. He told us the original idea was to call it Churchill’s, but trademark trouble pushed him to Chartwell, Winston Churchill’s longtime estate in Kent, England. He wanted it to feel like a friend’s basement or garage. Rob still calls it Chesterfields. It has never been called that, and Will took it better than I would have.
We bought every cigar we smoked that day from his humidor, because someone has to support the place that lets us film. He told us to pull the tables together and left us a few bottles of water. They rinse out the ashtrays. Will also sat in with a mic and told us he has brought in cigars he first heard about on the show, RoMA Craft among them. There are lounges closer to my garage. We drive down here anyway.
A Mild Label and a $30 Cigar at Noon
Eric lit a Davidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour. The name says it all. It’s an after-dinner cigar, and he was smoking it at noon on an empty stomach, and paid for it with a gift card. His tongue burned, his eyes watered, and he told us the room was spinning. By the end we were joking that he had thrown up. He hadn’t. He just looked like a guy who picked the wrong cigar for an early start.
It fit one of my show notes, which was about cigars with a mild label that don’t act mild. We agreed a Connecticut wrapper doesn’t mean mild anymore, and “mild” is starting to feel like an old word. The Ashton Cabinet came up as another one that hits harder than it says. We’re not all Connecticut guys, and a couple of us said so.
My other note was about brands that sell an “engineered” perfect draw. We called it a gimmick. Good rollers don’t need a slogan, and handmade cigars work because of tradition. Where we see real change is in the blends.
Will and the Acid Box Tobacco
Will told us the best story of the afternoon with a mic clipped on. A customer came in asking for loose tobacco. Will doesn’t sell any. The man said his wife got some there last week. Will was baffled, and Bruce was across the room hearing every word.
Then it clicked. Acid boxes ship with packing tobacco. Will walked him into the humidor and showed him. The guy sniffed it and said that was it. He had already rolled it in cigarette papers, smoked it, and loved it. Will told him he wasn’t sure it was safe, and the man said, “Dude, I already smoked it.” So Will put some in a bag for him.
After the guy left, Will and Bruce looked at each other. They Googled it and asked AI whether it was safe. Will wants the record clear that Chartwell does not condone smoking box packing material. We don’t either.
Joe Gets Invited On and Picks a Fat Bottom Betty
Joe is a listener and a regular at Chartwell. When he came in that day, we invited him to sit in. He’d always said he didn’t want to go on camera. We told him he was on now.
He picked a Fat Bottom Betty, an infused cigar, and he hated it. He said so, out loud, on the show. He couldn’t finish it, and he went back to the humidor and came back with a New World. Will told us infused cigars are his biggest seller, mostly to younger customers. Joe offered to be our boom guy as long as he never has to talk.
It was odd sitting somewhere that wasn’t the garage. Same people, same talk, but the room changed the vibe. We said we’d be back.
Stay in the Conversation
If you want to watch the episodes, the Stogie Review YouTube channel is the place, and Smoke and Steel is part of it. If you’d rather talk cigars with us during the week, come hang out in the Stogie Review Discord. And if you want to support the show, the Smoke and Steel Merch Store is open. Pull up a chair.
