Welcome back to another episode of the Smoke and Steel podcast! This week we’re tackling one of the most requested topics from our audience: finding quality smokes without breaking the bank. We dive deep into the best cigars under $10, discuss the controversial topic of aging cigars, and even connect with one of our crew members on the road for our first-ever “Eddie on the Street” segment.
Quick Congratulations Are in Order
Before we get into the cigar talk, we want to give a huge congratulations to one of our hosts on the recent arrival of his daughter Eleanor! It was quite the adventure at the hospital, and the full story is told in the episode, so make sure you watch to hear all the details. Welcome to the world, little one!
The Great Cigar Aging Debate
One topic that sparked some interesting conversation this week was cigar aging. With online ordering being so convenient these days, we discussed whether you still need to let cigars rest after they arrive at your door. The consensus? Times have changed.
Back in the day, conventional wisdom said you needed to let cigars acclimate for at least two weeks after ordering online. They’d arrive dry, and you’d have to baby them back to proper humidity. But now with Boveda packs included in just about every shipment, you can often smoke them right off the truck.
That said, we did identify some situations where resting is still important. If your delivery sits on a hot driveway for hours or gets stuck in a freezing mailbox, give those sticks some time to recover. Temperature extremes can mess with the moisture content, and a few days in your humidor will get them back to prime smoking condition.
The conversation naturally led to discussing aged cigars and whether older is always better. Some in the group swear by vintage smokes that have been sitting for 10-plus years, while others argued that cigars hit a peak and then start declining. We shared stories of cigars that improved dramatically with age and others that turned into duds after too much time in the humidor.
One interesting point that came up: manufacturers release cigars when they think they’re ready to smoke. They’ve already aged the tobacco before rolling. So when we age them further, we’re essentially experimenting beyond the blender’s intended profile. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t.
Best Cigars Under $10: Breaking Down the Budget Bangers
This segment was the highlight of the episode. We watched a video from Kyle at LA Cigar Collective where he shared his top five cigars under $10, then we went around the room sharing our own favorites.
Kyle’s list included some solid choices that got heads nodding around the table:
Charter Oak Shade Toro – This Foundation Cigar with an Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper was Kyle’s number one pick. Several of us have smoked boxes of Charter Oaks over the years. They’re reliable, well-made, and perfect for morning coffee or an afternoon on the golf course. While some noted the quality might not be quite what it used to be, they’re still a solid choice when you catch them on sale.
Buenaventura Pralines P554 – Kyle’s second pick from Curivari got mixed reactions from the group. Some of us weren’t fans of this particular blend, though Curivari as a brand has its devotees. They’re a boutique name that doesn’t get enough attention.
Tatuje Black Petite Robusto – This one generated excitement around the table. Multiple people in the room had boxes of these, and they’re regularly available online for around seven or eight bucks. The Tatuje Black line punches well above its weight class, delivering complex flavors in a small package.
Stolen Throne Yorktown Fleet – Stolen Throne has developed a cult following, and while this particular blend wasn’t everyone’s favorite from their lineup, it represents good value as one of their more affordable offerings.
My Father Fonseca – The ones wrapped in cedar got special mention as being significantly better than the standard version. These Nicaraguan smokes deliver that classic My Father quality at a fraction of the price of other offerings.
Our Additions to the Best Cigars Under $10 List
After Kyle’s video, we shared our own budget favorites:
The AJ Fernandez New World came up as a frequently purchased option, delivering a spicy, full-bodied experience for around eight bucks. For those who like a punch without the premium price tag, this one’s hard to beat. The AJ Fernandez New World Cameroon is also a great budget cigar from this lineup.
EP Carrillo Dusk got multiple mentions as an absolute steal at seven dollars. Some of us have gone through multiple boxes of these. They’re consistent, flavorful, and proof that you don’t need to spend a fortune for a satisfying smoke.
The CAO Amazon Basin Daggers generated enthusiasm as a newer release that’s already becoming a go-to short smoke. Even when there’s time for a longer cigar, these little daggers deliver enough flavor to make them worth reaching for.
Oliva Serie V and Melanio were discussed as cigars that are absolutely worth buying, but only when you catch them on sale online. The markup at brick-and-mortar shops can be significant, but online retailers frequently run deals that bring these well under the $10 range. The difference between shop prices and online prices for Oliva products is staggering.
Several CAO Flathead varieties made the list, particularly the black and red labels. These are solid golf course and lawn-mowing cigars that won’t make you cry if you have to ditch one halfway through.
The Exquisitos by Arturo Fuente got a shout-out as an often-overlooked gem from a legendary brand. When you think Fuente, you probably think Opus X or Don Carlos, but their more affordable lines deliver quality construction and flavor.
One key takeaway from this discussion: buying boxes online during sales is the way to maximize your budget. Many cigars that retail for $10-12 in shops can be found for $6-8 per stick when purchased by the box from online retailers. We mentioned Cigar Page specifically as a great resource for finding deals.
The Rise and Fall of Vegas Cigar Culture
We covered some industry news that’s pretty significant for cigar lovers. Casa Fuente, the iconic cigar lounge in Caesar’s Palace, is closing its doors. This marks a bigger trend of cigar-friendly spaces disappearing from Las Vegas.
The discussion highlighted how Vegas has changed over the years. What used to be an affordable destination where casinos comped meals and drinks has become increasingly expensive. Hotel rates, airfare, and rental cars have all skyrocketed. Combined with increasingly restrictive smoking policies, the city is losing some of its appeal for cigar enthusiasts.
Casa Fuente’s closure seems to stem from lease issues related to smoking on their “patio” (which was actually inside the Forum Shops). The brand has hinted they might reopen elsewhere, but it would need to be a prime location to justify the rent and foot traffic needed to sustain a premium cigar lounge.
Interestingly, we discussed whether Casa Fuente releasing their cigars for wider distribution a few years ago contributed to the problem. When these cigars were exclusive to the Vegas location, people made pilgrimages specifically to buy them. Once they became available everywhere, that unique draw disappeared. Why pay $20 extra per stick on the Strip when you can order them online for less?
Other Notable Mentions
We covered the news that Drew Estate and Joya de Nicaragua are ending their long-standing distribution agreement. Starting January 1st, 2026, Joya Nicaragua will handle their own distribution. It’s an interesting development that could change how we see Joya products marketed and sold.
The episode also featured our first “Eddie on the Street” segment, where one of our crew called in from Doc James Cigar Lounge in Mamaroneck, New York. While he didn’t go inside for this inaugural segment, we’re planning future installments where we’ll tour lounges, interview owners, and give viewers a look at cigar shops around the country.
The Bottom Line on Budget Smokes
The main message from this episode is clear: you absolutely do not need to spend $20 per cigar to have a great smoking experience. The best cigars under $10 category is loaded with quality options from respected brands. The key is knowing where to look, when to buy, and being willing to explore beyond the usual suspects.
Buy boxes when retailers run sales. Sign up for email alerts from online shops. Don’t be afraid to try boutique brands that might not have the name recognition of the big players. Some of the most satisfying smokes come from discovering that hidden gem that costs half what you’d normally spend.
And remember, expensive doesn’t always mean better. Sometimes that $25 cigar is absolutely worth it. Other times, a $7 stick delivers just as much satisfaction. It all comes down to personal preference, the occasion, and being smart about where you spend your cigar budget.
Support the Show
If you enjoyed this episode, we’d really appreciate your help spreading the word! Share this episode on social media and tag your cigar-loving friends. Word of mouth is huge for us, and it helps us continue bringing you weekly content.
Looking to stock up your humidor? Use our Cigar Page affiliate link when ordering online. It doesn’t cost you anything extra, but it helps support the show and keeps us recording every week.
Feeling extra generous? You can make a direct contribution through our Ko-Fi page. Every little bit helps us improve our equipment, bring on guests, and create better content for you.
Thanks for watching, and as always, keep those sticks lit!
