After smoking one of these gigantic pillars of multi-colored tobacco for a recent edition of Your Questions My Answers, I thought it might be fun to give it a proper review. As I mentioned in the video, I’m intrigued by cigars with multiple wrappers. They’re fun to look at (and to watch being rolled), they’re harder to make, and they add a little more danger to the burn. I find them immensely satisfying to watch when the dual wrappers burn properly, and even more satisfying to mention when they don’t. (Is that mean?)
If you saw the episode, you probably remember that I wasn’t terribly impressed with the cigar. (If you didn’t, why not? Go check it out!) But since it was the first I’d ever smoked, there was always the chance that it was a fluke. A one off. The Primer Mundo Rosado Oscuro I had in the next episode was a dud, and I know those are usually great. So it’s possible that this one was a fluke too. Heck, a slick write up of the cigar I read said it had a “zesty” flavor. Happily, I had a few more in my humidor to investigare. Here’s what I found.
Cigar Stats:
Size: 8.5 x 52
Wrapper:
Binder: Nicaraguan (?)
Filler: Dominican, Nicaraguan
Smoking Time: 2 1/2 hours
Beverage: Water
Price: ~$4.00
8 and a half inches of tobacco starts here…
The Pre-Smoke
A dos capas cigar is one you’ll definitely want to spend some time admiring before you smoke. (Not to mention before you buy!) Not only is it a work of incredible handiwork, it’s at least twice as susceptible to wrapper tears as your average cigar. Case in point, I found a tear in the maduro wrapper in the first third of this cigar.
With the wrapper contrast, a crack is hard to miss!
Beyond having a striking appearance, and massive size, I found it had a great scent. A very sweet compost aroma greeted my nose. As I made my way down to the foot, the compost scent became denser and stronger, and was joined by some chocolate. If the aroma is any indicator, I’m in for a fantastic smoke. I clipped the head with my flamboyantly-red Xikar and found the cold taste be a light combination of molasses and licorice. Very interesting indeed.
It’s hard to find too much wrong with the burn. For the most part, the burn line of this cigar was pretty even. It did stray at points, but never really got out of control, and never required my intervention. It also produced respectable ashes between 3/4 of an inch to nearly an inch and a half. The draw was also good, and the smoke was light and even. Overall I’d give the cigar good marks for the burn.
The first puff off this cigar is so very promising. I got a wonderful earthy flavor with a fantastically sweet toffee finish that lingered a long time. Unfortunately, every puff that followed it, down the entire 8 and a half inch length was a mere mild shadow of that first puff.
These are quite as easy to find as they were when I picked up my fiver a couple of months back. For quite a while, these were going for around $40 for a pack of then, or around $4 a stick. That’s a lot of tobacco and skilled rolling for the price, and it’s really hard to take issue with it.
My friends, what we have here is the Hawaiian shirt of cigars. It’s flashy, it isn’t terribly refined, and it has all the time in the world to linger on the beach with it’s pot belly hanging out. This cigar seems to be more about the message it sends out than the qualities of the contained tobacco. It says I have all the time in the world, and I want to you know it. I’m not saying the cigar is exactly bad, per se, there’s just not much in that acre of tightly rolled leaves under that pretty barber pole exterior. It appears that my first experience with this cigar was dead on.
Buy It Again: Unlikely
Recommend It: To mild cigar smokers with plenty of time
Here for your viewing pleasure is my trademark
I know this is a Man aize smoke, but come on you sould have gotten another inch out of that “nubb” easy.
Yeah, you’re right Big River Jake, and I thought about going the distance. To be honest, it started to get a bit boring, and I had some other things I needed to get done that evening! I definitely won’t claim that I nubbed this cigar!
I did take the one I smoked during the filming of YQMA a bit further down, but I was having a lot more fun then!
A great review. “The Hawaiian shirt of cigars” really seems to sum it up pretty well, plus it’s funny!
Thanks gusto1,
If I ever come out with a line of cigars, that’ll the slogan! And in the ads, I’ll probably BE wearing a Hawaiian shirt… LOL
As always a killer review. I’ve had a couple barber pole smokes, but not this one. I guess they can be geared for looks as opposed to substance. The only memorable one I’ve had was the 07 Camacho Liberty. Despite the hype of containing a sprinkle of pre-embargo Cuban, it really is a good smoke.
The tower of burn speaks for itself. If you were really diggin’ it, you’d have nubbed it.
-Tom
Thanks Tom,
So you enjoyed the 2007 Liberty? I have a couple of them resting in my humidor, and I’ve just never gotten around to trying them out. I’m not exactly saving them, but it just never seems to be the right time to pop open that cool little coffin they come in.
I did. The last one I had got a little harsh at the end, but the ones before that I enjoyed a lot. I like it so much that I got the entire box. Looking back, I’d never pay that much now of course. http://idiot0406.herfspace.com/blog/2007/08/06/camacho_liberty
Wow Tom,
You really did like it! A box has gotta run you around $300 at a B&M! But hey, the good news is if you hang on to some of ’em for a while you may be able to recoup some of those expenses selling them to other curious smokers.
Anyway the important thing is that you enjoyed them. An occasional splurge can be kinda fun.
Brian,
First of all… I’m an idiot. My amazing video work will show you the caliber of person you are dealing with 😉
Not that I completely regret the purchase, and I was given a little ‘break’ on the sticker shock. They are quite an enjoyable smoke, and very well constructed. I smoke one from time to time. I liked the actual cigar, and the individual numberd, screened coffins were a plus. As opposed to a neon humidor or whatever that thing is 🙂
The splurge was indeed fun, but I’m sticking to normal priced smokes these days. I’ll hang on to these for the rare special occasion.